Take a little leap into the unknown with our Mystery Bags! Each bag holds a surprise mix of handcrafted Pin and Paper favorites — including one boxed brooch card, one mini card, one flat pin card, and a fun sticker. Whether it’s for you or a friend, it’s the perfect way to unwrap a little magic for less. Select Christmas Bundle, Thank You Bundle, Encouragement Bundle, or Birthday Bundle.
Mini Mystery Bag - $25
These intriguing little bundles are packed with handcrafted surprises from the world of Pin and Paper—each one filled with a secret mix of cards, pins, and other delightful treasures.
Every bag is designed to spark curiosity and deliver joy, with a guaranteed blend of signature favorites and a few unexpected treats. Whether you choose the Mini Mystery Bag or go big with the Classic Mystery Bag, you’ll unwrap creativity, laughter, and a little bit of “wow.”
Perfect for gifting, collecting, or treating yourself—because sometimes the best surprises come wrapped in brown paper and sealed with mystery.
mini mystery bag, surprise gift bag, Pin and Paper mystery, boutique mystery gift, kraft bag Christmas bundle, handmade card mystery bag